Three doors and one decision: understand Monty Hall

After an empty door opens, does switching make any difference? The answer depends on how the host behaves. Work through all three possible prize locations.

Define the game before calculating

There are three doors and one prize, equally likely to be behind any door. You choose one. The host knows the prize location, always opens a different empty door and always offers a switch to the remaining closed door. These rules are part of the problem. A host who opens blindly or offers a switch only sometimes defines a different game.

Staying keeps your original bet

Your original door has a 1/3 chance of hiding the prize. Staying wins exactly when that first choice was correct. The host never moves the prize. Opening an empty door under these rules does not automatically turn your original choice into a fresh 1/2 bet. To compare strategies, examine when the initial choice was right.

Switching wins when you started wrong

If you chose an empty door, the prize is behind one of the other two. The host must open the other empty door, leaving the prize door closed. This happens in two of the three initial cases. If you chose the prize initially, switching loses. Thus staying wins in one of three cases and switching in two of three.

A fixed initial choice

Suppose you choose door 1. If the prize is in 1, staying wins and switching loses. If it is in 2, the host opens 3 and switching wins. If it is in 3, the host opens 2 and switching wins. When both remaining doors are empty, our example opens the lower-numbered one; that convention does not change the overall comparison between always staying and always switching.

What the table proves, and what it does not

The table below enumerates the three possible prize locations. It is neither real gameplay data nor a random simulation. The cases are equally likely by the initial assumption. A different first door changes their labels, not the advantage of switching. The exercise separates a game rule, a probability assumption and a conclusion. It is not advice to gamble money.

Frequently asked questions

Can the host reveal the prize?

Not under these rules. If that can happen, the problem changes and this calculation needs reconsidering.

Do two closed doors mean 50/50?

Not necessarily. Information depends on the process that left them closed. In the game defined here, switching has the advantage.

← All guides